Methodology development problems of financial and economic analysis for the purposes of tax control
Abstract
The article considers the history and specific features of financial and economic analysis methodic in Tax Service of Ukraine. Topic is up to date because of absence of commonly shared views at scope, methodic and necessity of financial analysis in spite of twenty years long studies history and plenty of methods tried. Analytical methods are of particular importance at the stages of taxpayer’s selection for tax audit and pre-check analysis. The article focuses on the reasons of this situation.
Author studies peculiarities of financial analysis methodic, applied by Tax service of Ukraine and Russian Federation. There are few concepts, describing the role and importance of financial analysis in State tax service practice, its interrelations with risk-oriented system of taxpayer’s selection for tax audit. Author describes different analytical methodologies, including typical soviet-style techno economic study, cabinet audit, integrated due diligence methodic, and the last one, combined with task risks evaluation. Article reviews comparative practice of analytical procedures in Ukrainian and Russian Tax services. It is concluded that focused at tax aspects financial analysis requires regulatory adjustment. This is especially important for pre-checking stage of tax audit, where it is interconnected but not limited with proving of earlier detected tax risks. The article is supposed to be useful for activities of Tax service of Ukraine.
Keywords
References
Lyst DPA Ukrai'ny vid 27.01.1998 № 759/10/20-2117 «Shhodo Metodychnyh rekomendacij po analizu finansovo-gospodars'kogo stanu pidpryjemstv ta organizacij» [The Statement of State Tax Administration of 27. 01. 1998 № 759/10/20-2117 «About Methodical recommendations as for analysis of enterprises’ and organizations financial and economic condition»]. (1998, 27 January). Retrieved from http://pro-u4ot. info/index. php?section=browse&CatID=156&ArtID=422 [in Ukrainian].
Nakaz DPA administracii' Ukrai'ny vid 25.11.2002 № 567 «Pro zatverdzhennja Metodychnyh rekomendacij z organizacii' kabinetnogo audytu (dlja jurydychnyh osib)» [The Order of State Tax Administration of 25.11.2002 № 567 «On approval of Methodical recommendations for organization of cabinet audit of incorporated person»]. (2002, 25 November). Retrieved from http://zakon. nau.ua/doc/?doc_id=139999 [in Ukrainian].
Nakaz Ministerstva finansiv Ukrai'ny vid 14.02.2006 № 170 «Pro zatverdzhennja Metodyky analizu finansovo-gospodars'koi' dijal'nosti pidpryjemstv derzhavnogo sektoru ekonomiky» [The Order of Ministry of finance of 14.02.2006 № 170 «On approval of Methodic of financial and economic analysis for public sector incorporated person»]. (2002, 25 November). Retrieved from http://zakon2.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/z0332-06 [in Ukrainian].
Lyst DPA Ukrai'ny vid 17.03.2009 r. № 2393/7/23-308 «Shhodo zdijsnennja analizu finansovo-gospodars'koi' dijal'nosti pry provedenni perevirok». [The Statement of State Tax Administration of 17.03.2009 r. № 2393/7/23-308 «About conducting of financial and economic analysis under tax audit»]. (2009, 17 March). Retrieved from http://zakon. nau.ua/doc/?doc_id=244314. [in Ukrainian].
Nakaz DPA Ukrai'ny vid 01.04.2011 r. № 190 «Pro zatverdzhennja Metodychnyh rekomendacij shhodo skladannja planu-grafika provedennja dokumental'nyh planovyh perevirok sub'jektiv gospodarjuvannja» [The Order of State Tax Administration of 01.04.2011 r. № 190 «On approval of Methodical recommendations for scheduling of planned documental tax audits of incorporated persons»]. (2011, 01 April). Retrieved from http://zakon. nau.ua/doc/?doc_id=627233 [in Ukrainian].
Nakaz DPS Ukrai'ny vid 27.06.2012 r. № 553 «Pro zatverdzhennja Metodychnyh rekomendacij shhodo skladannja planu-grafika provedennja dokumental'nyh planovyh perevirok sub'jektiv gospodarjuvannja» [The Order of State Tax Service of 27.06.2012 r. № 553 «On approval of Methodical recommendations for scheduling of planned documental tax audits of incorporated persons»]. (2012, 27 June). Retrieved from http://zakon. nau.ua/doc/?doc_id=782261 [in Ukrainian]
Metodycheskye rekomendacyy provedenyja nalogovogo monytorynga y predproverochnogo analyza na osnove sredneotraslevыh yndykatorov. Prykaz FNS Rossyy ot 23 yjulja 2009 g. № MM-8-l24. [The Order of Federal Tax Service of Russian Federation 23.07.2009 r. № MM-8-l24 «Methodical recommendations for tax monitoring and pre-checking analysis based on average industrial indicators»]. (2009, 23 July). Retrieved from http://base. consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online. cgi [in Russian].
Kak nalogovyky budut yskat' pryznaky nalogovыh shem v otchetnosty kompanyj. (17.09.2009) [What are procedures for searching of tax schemes, used by tax auditors], Fynansovij dyrektor. Retrieved from: http://fd.ru/articles/36969-kak-nalogoviki-budut-iskat-priznaki-nalogovyh-shem-v-otchetnosti-kompaniy#ixzz3bjAfEehN.
Udalov R. V. (2012). Prymenenye analytycheskyh ynstrumentov pry osushhestvlenyy nalogovogo kontrolja (predproverochnyj analyz). [Analitical procedures, used under tax control (pre-check analysis)], Nalogy y nalogooblozhenye, 5, 33-37.
Article Metrics
Metrics powered by PLOS ALM
Refbacks
Copyright (c)
Articles are distributed under Creative Commons Attribution International 4.0 (CC-BY-NC 4.0)
Science Works Journal "Ekonomichnyy analiz"
ISSN 1993-0259 (Print) ISSN 2219-4649 (Online) DOI: 10.35774/econa
© West Ukrainian National University
© «Ekonomichnyy analiz», 2007-2023